Monday, 19 March 2012

Red State directed by Kevin Smith


Red State is a complete 180 for Kevin Smith. Unlike anything he has done before, Red State is a hybrid thriller/action/horror flick with very little humour. It stars Michael Parks, John Goodman and Melissa Leo and (unlike Cop Out) is written by Smith. Low Budget, well acted and intense, Red State was exactly what I expected; A fairly decent thrill ride that, like most of Smith's body of work sits on the fence between being okay and being great.

After Smith worked as a director for hire on Cop Out, he returns to writing, producing, editing and directing with this film. And like much of his work, it is the dialogue that really stands out.  The story concerns 3 teenage boys who find a woman online who is prepared to sleep with them no questions asked. They show up, get drugged and wake up to find themselves captured by a devout religious cult hell bent on sending sinners to the grave.  The first five minutes are actually rather funny and could really fit into the rest of the Kevin Smith oeuvre but once the boys arrive at the woman's house the humour becomes minimal and the violence and terror begins.  The last third of the film shy's away from the terror and the humour and seems to become an action film.  And after all this, the very last scene and moment before the credits roll, makes the viewer laugh.

Like I said it is the dialogue that stands out, and this is very apparent every time Michael Parks appears on screen. His maniacal religious beliefs, his love for his family and his murderous rage all come out in a pitch perfect performance that not only holds the film together but is the main reason why the film and the emotions the viewer feels works so well. The other performances in the film come off pretty well too, but Parks outshines everybody including the very talented Melissa Leo.

There are times in Red State where the editing could of been a little tighter. Already a short film, clocking in at just shy of 90 minutes, it could of benefited from maybe being 5 minutes shorter.  A few too long speeches and a somewhat over long third act make the film less affecting than it otherwise could be. Smith`s direction is solid, not award worthy, but a hell of a lot better than his last film and considering he`s working out of his element here, in a genre he`s never touched before, he does a fairly good job. The film looks good, is sharply filmed and has some good production design but as a whole it feels slightly cheaper and more lacking than it should.

After some heavy deliberation I found that this is caused by the sound and music of the film.   The music tracks selected for the film work well, but the score is minimalist and leaves the viewer with nothing. Nothing while watching the film and an even bigger nothing when it ends. The sound design to is not anything to write home about. It works fine in the film but it just doesn`t have any `oomph`. Things just happen, sounds just happen and there is no flare to any of the sound design in regards to the special effects, dialogue and music. This kind of sound design is much better suited to the type of films Smith has made in the past.

With that said, there is still much to enjoy in Red State. If you like horror movies (although this film is not a flat out horror) then you`ll like this film. If you like Kevin Smith and know anything about him then you`ll like this film. It`s not fantastic, but it`s most definitely worth a viewing or two.

Film Rating: 69%

Breakdown (How Red State scored 69%):

Production Design: 7 out of 10
Cinematography: 6 out of 10
Re-playability: 7 out of 10
Originality: 7 out of 10
Costumes: 7 out of 10
Directing: 7 out of 10
Editing: 7 out of 10
Acting: 8 out of 10
Music: 6 out of 10
Script: 7 out of 10

Thursday, 15 March 2012

Cop Out directed by Kevin Smith

When I saw Cop Out in the theatres I was terribly disappointed. Now after watching Kevin Smith's first eight films, I thought to myself 'maybe Cop Out will be better than I remember it'. After all, I did like Dogma more so than I did the first time. So after watching it again I can tell you that it did not improve and was still the dull, boring, painfully unfunny and terribly directed movie that I remember seeing those many months ago.

What went wrong with Cop Out. It was directed by Smith, who usually does, if not a great job, a passable job and it stars Bruce Willis and Tracey Morgan as cops trying to bust a drug kingpin. This premise and talent alone should of made for a half decent movie, but instead we are left with nothing more than bad humour, bad acting and terrible directing.

Let's start with the script. For the first time Smith has directed a film not written by himself and what a lame script he has chosen to do. The humour that is ever so present in his previous films has disappeared. Instead we get lame jokes, bad mugging for the camera and a barrage of unfunny material that actually thinks it's funny. Tracey Morgan, in 107 minutes is maybe funny in five.  The only funny character and funny moments come from Sean William Scott, who is only in the film for maybe ten minutes and even then they aren't laugh out loud funny. Mallrats, although not a great film, was at least hilarious. The story itself is fairly weak and for a buddy cop movie, it's fairly light on action and humour and it doesn't delve into any areas we haven't seen before. It's predictable and juvenile, it's full of plot holes, and it's got a rather lame ending that doesn't deliver on what comes before.

The actors in this film you would hope would deliver but they don't.Willis is tame and basically phones in his performance and Morgan gives a performance that will keep him on the small screen rather than the silver screen for years to come.  Populated with mostly TV stars in supporting roles the film feels like a TV movie. And why hire Kevin Pollack in a comedy if he's not going to make jokes? What's the point in that.

But the worst thing about Cop Out, worse than the acting and worse than the script and worse than the music which sounds like a cheap knock off of the Beverly Hills Cop theme, is the direction. Smith, who I never felt was a great director is done an absolutely terrible job here. Most scenes aren't put together well and there are some scenes, like the interrogation scene, that feel like each actor was filmed at different times and then hastily edited together. And the action scenes, especially the car chase are some of the most poorly filmed and boring action scenes I have ever laid eyes on.  Smith is no action director, and apparently, if he doesn't write the script he is no director at all.


Film Rating: 44%

Breakdown (How Cop Out scored 44%):

Production Design: 6 out of 10
Cinematography: 5 out of 10
Re-playability: 3 out of 10
Originality: 5 out of 10
Costumes: 6 out of 10
Directing: 4 out of 10
Editing: 4 out of 10
Acting: 5 out of 10
Music: 3 out of 10
Script: 3 out of 10

Wednesday, 7 March 2012

Zack and Miri Make a Porno directed by Kevin Smith


Zack and Miri Make a Porno (ZAMP) is the eighth film from Kevin Smith and the second film (after Jersey Girl) that doesn't play into the universe or characters that he created and used in all his previous films (Jersey Girl withstanding).  This film, is raunchy, funny, sweet and enjoyable. At the same time it is is full of cheesy sentiment, jokes revolving around shit and an incredible amount of swearing, for no other reason except to be foul.

ZAMP stars Seth Rogen and Elizabeth Banks in the leads, and Jason Mewes and Craig Robinson in supporting roles.  As usual Mewes is great in his role as a dimwitted guy who gets casted in the porno of said title.  Banks and Rogen fair well together and have great chemistry on the screen but it is Robinson who ends up stealing the picture under everybody's noses (Justin Long appears in a brief cameo that comes close to being the funniest scene in the movie). Robinson, of The Office fame, is comedy gold in ZAMP.  He is laugh out loud funny, and everyone pales in comparison to him including the usual scene stealer himself, Seth Rogen.

The story concerns two roommates who are down on their luck and down on funds. One night they decide to make a porn film to help make ends meet.  What ensues is a barrage of sex jokes, nudity and foul language that works for the most part, but leaves the viewer feeling a little empty by the time the credits role. Smith, who usually writes incredible dialogue and original story ideas seems to have lost a bit of his magic touch here. ZAMP is still really funny, and scattered throughout the film are some great one-liners and stellar dialogue that Smith is famous for, but for the most part the jokes and the storyline follow a conventional and unoriginal path. The porn titles that Rogen and Banks and other cast members go through are nothing that haven't been said before or used  a thousand times in similar contexts and the final title that they come up with (for their first porno attempt) is just weak.

And then there are the expected shit, ass and penis jokes that Smith seems to always feel the need to put in his movies. Unlike Clerks (1 and 2), Dogma and his other films, Smith's predilection for this type of humour works much better in ZAMP. Not to say they aren't gross or juvenile, but these jokes fit much better into the subject matter. Porn works much better for this kind of humour than say religion ala Dogma.

And even though the film is enjoyable, and funny and keeps you watching from start to finish, there is an air of predictability to the story. You can see the ending coming a mile away and are left with a feeling of been there, done that. That is to say, when the final credits role you feel as though you haven't really seen anything new. That's because Smith's writing is usually sharp, smart and authentic but in ZAMP for the most part it comes off as just the opposite.

The production design is pretty good for this film. Sets look real, outsides feel cold, and costumes look good, especially the Star Wars themed porn film props and costumes.  The music is unmemorable and as I write this review I can't remember a single musical cue.  Smith's direction is fairly solid and you can see he has come along way since Clerks. (student film like) and the poorly directed Mallrats. The editing is pretty good too, making the movie progress at a steady pace, but a few scenes could of been a little tighter.

ZAMP is a funny film. It's chock full of sex and nudity and funny performances and it's got a touching and sweet resolution if somewhat cheesy and conventional.  This doesn't rank up there as a great film, or even as a great Kevin Smith film but if you are a fan of his, or a fan of raunchy humour, I could think of worse ways to spend an hour and forty minutes

Film Rating: 68%

Breakdown (How Zack and Miri Make a Porno scored 68%):

Production Design: 7 out of 10
Cinematography: 7 out of 10
Re-playability: 7 out of 10
Originality: 7 out of 10
Costumes: 7 out of 10
Directing: 7 out of 10
Editing: 7 out of 10
Acting: 7 out of 10
Music: 6 out of 10
Script: 6 out of 10

2AG9SVKPGUFX

Saturday, 3 March 2012

Clerks II directed by Kevin Smith


After making a slight departure with Jersey Girl, Kevin Smith returns to the world he created, and the film that got him noticed with Clerks II.  Featuring most of the cast from the original film, a bigger budget and the same solid writing that has encapsulated all his previous films, Clerks II fares a lot better than one would expect.

Not the greatest film in the Smith cannon,  Clerks II is still a fun watch with some hilarious and outrageous scenes that need to be seen to believed.  In a return to his early style (Clerks., Mallrats and Chasing Amy), Clerks II is based around characters standing around and talking. Unlike the original film though, the sequel has more of a story than before.  Both Dante and Randall are back, but this time they are older (maybe a little wiser) and are working at a fast food joint rather than a convenience store. Their characters move through a story that gives them more to do than spout off insults and jokes and allows the viewers the chance to feel something for the characters and understand them better than they did before.

The acting is, like Clerks, okay by the two leads, but Rosario Dawson outshines everyone in her role and makes it hard pressed for anyone not to fall in love with her.  She really does light up the screen every time she appears and makes for a great character to play against both Dante and Randall.  And as usual, Smith has littered his film with cameos from people like Wanda Sykes, Ben Affleck and Jason Lee.

While not a original as Clerks. (how can it be being a sequel for one thing and being 12 years after the original for another), Clerks II is still really funny and will have you laughing from the opening credits to the end credits.  Star Wars vs. Lord of the Rings, a welcome return for Jay and Silent Bob, and a donkey make for some uproarious scenes that rival the first film for more quotable and memorable scenes. And again, unlike Clerks., the sequel contains a couple moments (not many) of drama that makes for a more well rounded arc than said original.

The editing is a lot tighter than Clerks. and rightfully making the film feel a lot more professional than the original. Shot in colour, using more than one location, strong camera movements, a musical number and a few special effects makes Clerks II a stronger film in those regards than Clerks. but the script overall isn't as original, funny or clever as it's predecessor.  Smith does a great job behind the scenes of this film, showing what a strong confident director he has become over the years, and although he still wouldn't be considered an award winning director, he has learned to handle all aspects of the production quite well since his beginnings as a director.

Film Rating: 70%

Breakdown (How Clerks II scored 70%):

Production Design: 7 out of 10
Cinematography: 7 out of 10
Re-playability: 7 out of 10
Originality: 6 out of 10
Costumes: 6 out of 10
Directing: 7 out of 10
Editing: 8 out of 10
Acting: 7 out of 10
Music: 7 out of 10
Script: 8 out of 10

Tuesday, 28 February 2012

Jersey Girl directed by Kevin Smith


Wait a second? Does the title really say Kevin Smith directed this film? Really? And he wrote it? Come on, someone's pulling my leg, no? After watching Smith's first five movies, and then watching Jersey Girl, I couldn't believe that the same man wrote and directed them.

And I must admit, I was hesitant going into Jersey Girl. It came and went in theatres, was bad mouthed as another bad Affleck/Lopez comedy, and then disappeared into somewhat obscurity over the last few years. Hesitant as I was, I popped in the movie and was rather surprised at how much I enjoyed it.

Right from the first scene, it feels different from other Kevin Smith films and that feeling stays throughout the picture.  Gone is the crude and vulgar humor that was present in all his other films, gone are Jay and Silent Bob, and gone are the poop jokes that so far have been scattered throughout his filmography.

Instead we get a mature, well written comedy-drama about a widowed man and his daughter.  There are some very funny moments throughout Jersey Girl, some amusing moments and then there are the dramatic moments.  The story revolves around Ben Affleck and his daughter and the ideas of family and home and the choices we make. Smith's screenplay is, as usual, littered with great dialogue and funny scenes but this time he gives his characters more to do than laugh and say funny things. They have motives, they make choices that effect other people, they are more real than anything he has done, save for Chasing Amy (although this is less of a comedy than that).

And then look of the film, again, right from the start doesn't look like a Kevin Smith film.  Right away the camera is moving, following characters, moving through city skys and zooming in through windows.  The cinematography is crisp and colourful and glitzy. Lights sparkle, metals glisten, the sun radiates and tears shimmer in the gloriously framed shots that Smith and his team have captured.  Except for Dogma, Jersey Girl is the only film in Smith's oeuvre that isn't static, flat and unimaginative.  It is beautifully shot and captured by the legendary and talented Vilmos Zsigmond, giving more life to the picture than it rightfully deserves.

Smith, who edits his own films with partner Scott Mosier, when watching the footage must of been inspired to do a better job editing than he has previously.  In the past his editing worked but was slightly jumpy and shots didn't necessarily flow together so well, but here along with the gorgeous photography we get the most professional and well put together film of Kevin Smith's career, giving me reason to once again believe that Smith does have quite a bit of talent other than being a great writer.

That's not to say Jersey Girl is a phenomenal movie that deserves rave reviews and plenty of awards. To start with, the story is wholly unoriginal. The story of a single parent raising their child has been done too many times to count on the big screen. And there are a few overly sentimental scenes in the movie, not too many, but enough to warrant their mention.

For a comedy, and for Smith, the humour is somewhat lacking.  There are amusing bits and funny bits but nothing that makes you laugh out loud, something Smith is very good at making the viewer do.  He goes for a more adult tone in Jersey Girl, more than any previous attempt, but in doing so he neglects his skills in comedy writing, which is all the more upsetting when you think about the cast he gathered for this film.  It would of been great to see George Carlin, Jason Biggs, Stephen Root and others delivering some of that trademark Smith wit, but ultimately their characters are a big let down as they remain too much in the background.

When Jersey Girl is over it will leave you with a smile on your face. It's an enjoyable movie with some nice humour, tender and likeable characters and some truly stunning (for a comedy) cinematography.  It's sweet and touching and very likeable, but it's lack of strong side characters and unoriginal story will make Jersey Girl a distant memory sooner than it rightfully should.



Film Rating: 72%

Breakdown (How Jersey Girl scored 72%):

Production Design: 7 out of 10
Cinematography: 9 out of 10
Re-playability: 7 out of 10
Originality: 5 out of 10
Costumes: 7 out of 10
Directing: 7 out of 10
Editing: 8 out of 10
Acting: 8 out of 10
Music: 7 out of 10
Script: 7 out of 10

Monday, 27 February 2012

Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back directed by Kevin Smith (70%)

Kevin Smith's fifth film, Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back, is the culmination of all his films that came before.  It takes place in the same world as Clerks., Mallrats, Chasing Amy and Dogma. It features, besides Jay and Silent Bob, many of the characters that feature in those previous films as well as featuring cameos from a slew of other famous names and faces.

After watching Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back (I'm just going to call it Strike Back from now on), I just wasn't sure how I felt about this film. On one hand, it's hilarious; from start to finish, Strike Back features some true gems of comedy.. Even better, the film features Jay and Silent Bob in the leads and after four films where they were featured in the sidelines, its great to see them again where they do a great job throughout as the leads of the film. Ben Affleck, Matt Damon, Carrie Fisher, George Carlin, Chris Rock and Mark Hamill amongst many others make some really amusing cameos. And I can't not mention how sexy both Eliza Dushku and Shannon Elizabeth look in this film.

Smith's dialogue really is great in this film. With in-jokes about Hollywood, celebrities making fun of themselves, and some real obscure situations that Strike Back puts the characters in, the viewer is sure to have a good time.  Now I say that the writing is fantastic and the humour is laugh out loud funny and it is true, but like Dogma and Mallrats, Smith throws in some real juvenile humour that just doesn't fit into the rest of the film. His tendency to include an over abundance of poop jokes really brings down the level of his films (which is one of the main reasons why Chasing Amy shines over all other Kevin Smith productions).

Unlike Dogma, the poop jokes aren't the only thing that brings down Strike Back. With Chasing Amy, Smith showed a maturity that wasn't in his two films. He showed he was growing as a director. Then with Dogma, he bloomed.  Dogma looked phenomenal, was striking in it's colours and sets and special effects, and the camera no longer just shot the scenes it became an integral part of the film bringing the viewer into the story and making them feel for the characters. But his direction here seems to revert back to his Mallrats days, and after watching Dogma, it is such a disappointment. The static photography that I hoped was gone was back, and with so much  action and movement in the story, it really made the film feel flat.  It should have looked and felt like Dogma, but instead we the viewer are kept at a distance from everything that we experience on screen.  It makes the film feel choppy, as if we are watching a bunch of scenes haphazardly put together, instead of a well made cohesive story.

But, I digress. Poop jokes and shoddy direction aside, Strike Back is well worth watching if you want to laugh straight for just shy of two hours. If you take the funniest parts of Clerks., Mallrats, Chasing Amy and Dogma and string them together, you still won't laugh as hard as you do in this movie.  (And a word to the wise: This movie will make a whole lot more sense if you have seen all four of Smith's previous films.) (And one more word to the wise: See Good Will Hunting before you see this film.)


Film Rating: 70%

Breakdown (How Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back scored 70%):

Production Design: 7 out of 10
Cinematography: 6 out of 10
Re-playability: 8 out of 10
Originality: 8 out of 10
Costumes: 7 out of 10
Directing: 6 out of 10
Editing: 7 out of 10
Acting: 7 out of 10
Music: 7 out of 10
Script: 7 out of 10

Wednesday, 22 February 2012

Dogma directed By Kevin Smith (79%)

Dogma is a strange beast of a movie. It is at times hilarious, smart and dramatic while at other times it is juvenile, misguided and irrational. The fourth movie from Kevin Smith, Dogma, plays out nicely but leaves the viewer slightly empty after watching the film.

The plot concerns two angels, Ben Affleck and Matt Damon, who have been banned from heaven and have found a loop hole that will get them back in. At the same time, a woman, Linda Fiorentino, is charged by God to stop them.  The movie races from one scene to the next, leaving no time to breathe. Joke after joke comes flying at the viewer, while at the same time philosophical banter on religion comes just as fast.  Like Clerks. and Mallrats, this movie is made up of a whole mesh of scenes that form a cohesive whole.  Unlike those movies though, there is a strong story that is told as the movie plays out.

Coming after Chasing Amy, an absolutely fantastic low budget romantic comedy, Smith's Dogma just seems to pale in comparison. The movie tells a story but the scenes and dialogue come at you so fast that there is never time to digest what just happened.  Just as you are thinking about the last scene, or about the comedic repertoire spouted out by one of the characters, or the commentary on christianity (or religion in general) that is rather astute in it's logic, Smith throws another of those three motifs at you.  You forget about what it was that made you think, or laugh and you move on to the next piece. About 90 percent of the film plays out this way.  If Dogma was a straight out comedy, like Clerks., then this wouldn't be a problem, but considering the dramatic theme on religion that is inherent in the script, the movie just doesn't play out as well as it could.  Even though the film feels a tad too long at it's just over two hour runtime, the film could of been a wee bit longer to flesh out the ideas that Smith is trying to convey.

That aside, the only other complaint I have with Dogma is that at times it comes off as rather tepid. Bodily function jokes and cheap shots at sex and religion are in abundance, and again, in the right context this type of humor works a hell of a lot better.  Chasing Amy showed a more mature side of Kevin Smith. It was far more sophisticated than Mallrats and even Clerks.. Dogma tries real hard to reach the same heights as, and even soar past, Chasing Amy and there are fleeting glimpses of it succeeding but ultimately the poop joke overshadows the rest of the film.

One last thing before I move to the positives of Dogma. There are many a plot hole in this film.  There is one glaring one that cannot be mentioned, in lieu of giving away a major plot point, but one that frustrated me to no end.  The rest of them, I think could easily of been avoided if the movie was a few minutes longer.

Okay, onto the good things about Dogma.

The acting in this film is pretty damn good.  All the leads are excellent and even though I usually don't like Chris Rock, he was pretty damn good too.  Fiorentino exudes cool and sexy, Alan Rickman is strong as ever and Affleck and Damon are always fun to watch together. But this film belongs to Jay and Silent Bob (Jason Mewes and Kevin Smith). Having made somewhat brief appearances in Smith's previous three films, they return as major characters this time around. The two together are uproarious and are a joy to watch.

And Smith's direction of the action is better than anything he has done before.  Chasing Amy delivered on a promise he showed in Clerks. and Dogma expands on that delivery.  Shooting for the first time in the scope ratio of 2.35, Smith and his crew have made a beautiful looking film. With rich colours, beautiful framed shots and more camera movement than Clerks., Mallrats and Chasing Amy combined, Dogma stands out as the first Kevin Smith film that is more than just a screenplay. Smith has a much bigger budget to play with this time around and he uses it to great effect.

And the sound. I can't not mention the sound. Smith's previous films have all sounded flat. They didn't need much in way of sound but still, they were rather flat and tinny with not much in production value. Not Dogma! Nu-uh! Armed with a great score by Howard Shore and a rich and lustful sound effects track, Dogma sounds awesome.  It's clear, it's loud, it's enveloping; it's a thing of beauty.

Kudos Mr. Smith on your fourth feature film. It's nice to see you blossoming into such a fine director, much better than what you gave the world in Mallrats. Dogma is a good film, it's witty and smart and is fun to watch right from the get go. It's just a shame that it comes off as so inconsequential. A movie that tackles the subjects that Dogma does should leave the viewer thinking long after the credits role. Sadly, after watching Dogma, all one is left with at the end of the day is a hazy memory of a poop joke.


Film Rating: 79%

Breakdown (How Dogma scored 79%):

Production Design: 8 out of 10
Cinematography: 8 out of 10
Re-playability: 8 out of 10
Originality: 9 out of 10
Costumes: 8 out of 10
Directing: 8 out of 10
Editing: 7 out of 10
Acting: 8 out of 10
Music: 8 out of 10
Script: 7 out of 10